Message-ID: <12054207.1075858670493.JavaMail.evans@thyme>
Date: Thu, 20 Sep 2001 16:04:51 -0700 (PDT)
From: jshohet@graycary.com
To: mark.hamer@enron.com, ezickson.doron@enron.com, fergus.gary@enron.com, 
	mcmahon.gerald@enron.com, ransom.james@enron.com, 
	frizzell.jean@enron.com, davidson.jeffrey@enron.com, 
	hein.jennifer@enron.com, costa.jennifer@enron.com, 
	hershberger.john@enron.com, roppe.laura@enron.com, 
	peters.mary@enron.com, leone.michael@enron.com, 
	weaver.michael@enron.com, kirby.michael@enron.com, 
	smith.mike@enron.com, b..sanders@enron.com, c..williams@enron.com, 
	"mr." <.robin@enron.com>, herman.stephen@enron.com, 
	michel.sydne@enron.com, murphy.tanya@enron.com, 
	richardson.tony@enron.com, goldberg.alex@enron.com, 
	edwards.brady@enron.com, bailey.brent@enron.com, 
	merryman.bryan@enron.com, varner.carlton@enron.com, 
	zdebski.charles@enron.com, pallenik.christine@enron.com, 
	healey.christopher@enron.com, packard.connie@enron.com, 
	butswinkas.dane@enron.com, pickett.donn@enron.com, 
	tribble.douglas@enron.com, kohnke.ernie@enron.com, 
	halling.gary@enron.com, bestor.geofrey@enron.com, 
	copeland.greg@enron.com, allen.gretchen@enron.com, 
	brown.heather@enron.com, davenport.hugh@enron.com, 
	kelly.hugh@enron.com, beh.james@enron.com, springer.james@enron.com, 
	shohet.jeffrey@enron.com, russell.joann@enron.com, 
	paul.joe@enron.com, kleinman.joel@enron.com, newton.joel@enron.com, 
	herbert.john@enron.com, gammie.john@enron.com, brooks.john@enron.com, 
	leslie.john@enron.com, karp.joseph@enron.com, 
	tiffany.joseph@enron.com, sauntry.june@enron.com, 
	forrest.kirk@enron.com, eisenstat.larry@enron.com, 
	lane.linda@enron.com, cottle.lisa@enron.com, miller.lisa@enron.com, 
	mcconnell.lynn@enron.com, hernandez.lynne@enron.com, 
	perlis.mark@enron.com, sottosanti.martha@enron.com, 
	maxwell.melissa@enron.com, kass.michael@enron.com, 
	jines.mike@enron.com, nissen.neha@enron.com, 
	pedersen.norman@enron.com, kadzik.peter@enron.com, 
	holcomb.r.@enron.com, wiegmann.r.@enron.com, coleman.ran@enron.com, 
	mcmanus.randy@enron.com, edwards.robert@enron.com, 
	fallon.robert@enron.com, steiner.robert@enron.com, 
	harris.scott@enron.com, jeff.shohet@enron.com, 
	raber.stephen@enron.com, houlihan.terry@enron.com, 
	hixson.thomas@enron.com, kennedy.thomas@enron.com, 
	muller.tim@enron.com, taylor.timothy@enron.com, 
	proctor.veronica@enron.com, starbird.zackary@enron.com
Subject: 0155770.pdfopenelement.pdf
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
X-From: "Shohet, Jeff" <jshohet@graycary.com>@ENRON <IMCEANOTES-+22Shohet+2C+20Jeff+22+20+3Cjshohet+40graycary+2Ecom+3E+40ENRON@ENRON.com>
X-To: Hamer, Mark <mhamer@graycary.com>, Doron Ezickson <dezickson@mwe.com>, Gary Fergus <gfergus@brobeck.com>, Gerald L. McMahon <mcmahon@scmv.com>, James Ransom <james_ransom@la.kirkland.com>, Jean Frizzell <jfrizzell@gibbs-bruns.com>, Jeffrey Davidson <jeffrey_davidson@la.kirkland.com>, Jennifer A. Hein <jennifer.hein@neg.pge.com>, Jennifer Costa <jennifer.costa@neg.pge.com>, John Hershberger <hershberger@scmv.com>, Laura H. Roppe <roppe@scmv.com>, Mary Lou Peters <marylou.peters@msdw.com>, Michael A. Leone <leone@scmv.com>, Michael J. Weaver <mike.weaver@lw.com>, Michael L. Kirby <mlk@pkns.com>, Mike D. Smith <msmith1@enron.com>, Sanders, Richard B. </O=ENRON/OU=NA/CN=RECIPIENTS/CN=RSANDER>, Williams, Robert C. </O=ENRON/OU=NA/CN=RECIPIENTS/CN=RWILLIA2>, Robin Gibbs (Mr.) <sbishop@gibbs-bruns.com>, Stephen A. Herman <steve.herman@neg.pge.com>, Sydne Michel <sydne_michel@la.kirkland.com>, Tanya Murphy <tanya.murphy@neg.pge.com>, Tony Richardson <tony_richardson@la.kirkland.com>, Alex Goldberg <alex.goldberg@williams.com>, Brady Edwards <brady.edwards@bakerbott.com>, Brent Bailey <bbailey@duke-energy.com>, Bryan A. Merryman <bmerryman@whitecase.com>, Carlton Varner <cvarner@smrh.com>, Charles Zdebski <charles.zdebski@troutmansanders.com>, Christine M. Pallenik <cmpallenik@duke-energy.com>, Christopher J. Healey <CHealey@luce.com>, Connie Packard <Connie.Packard@williams.com>, Dane Butswinkas <dbutswinkas@wc.com>, Donn Pickett <dpickett@mdbe.com>, Douglas Tribble <dtribble@PillsburyWinthrop.com>, Ernie Kohnke <Ernie.Kohnke@DYNEGY.COM>, Gary Halling <ghalling@smrh.com>, Geofrey Bestor <BestorG@dsmo.com>, Greg Copeland <gcopeland@bakerbotts.com>, Gretchen Allen <gallen@bakerbotts.com>, Heather Brown <heather.brown@williams.com>, Hugh Davenport <hugh.davenport@southernenergy.com>, Hugh Rice Kelly <light-kelly@reliantenergy.com>, James C. Beh <james.beh@troutmansanders.com>, James Springer <springerj@dsmo.com>, Jeffrey Shohet <jshohet@graycary.com>, JoAnn Russell <jprussell@duke-energy.com>, Joe Paul <jmpa@dynegy.com>, Joel Kleinman <KleinmanJ@dsmo.com>, Joel Newton <jdne@dynegy.com>, John C. Herbert <jche@dynegy.com>, John Gammie <john.gammie@williams.com>, John T. Brooks <JTBrooks@luce.com>, John W. Leslie <JLeslie@luce.com>, Joseph M. Karp <jkarp@whitecase.com>, Joseph Tiffany <jtiffany@PillsburyWinthrop.com>, June Ann Sauntry <juneann.sauntry@troutmansanders.com>, Kirk Forrest <kirk.forrest@williams.com>, Larry Eisenstat <EisenstatL@dsmo.com>, Linda Lane <llane@graycary.com>, Lisa Cottle <lcottle@whitecase.com>, Lisa Miller <millerl@dsmo.com>, Lynn McConnell <Lynn.McConnell@williams.com>, Lynne Hernandez <lhernandez@luce.com>, Mark Perlis <PerlisM@dsmo.com>, Martha Sottosanti <msottosanti@smrh.com>, Melissa Maxwell <mmaxwell@bakerbotts.com>, Michael Kass <mkass@PillsburyWinthrop.com>, Mike Jines <mike-jines@reliantenergy.com>, Neha Shah Nissen <nnissen@mdbe.com>, Norman Pedersen <napedersen@jonesday.com>, Peter Kadzik <KadzikP@dsmo.com>, R. Bruce Holcomb <HolcombB@dsmo.com>, R. Hackney (Hack) Wiegmann <hwiegmann@wc.com>, Ran Coleman <rcoleman@duke-energy.com>, Randy McManus <rmcmanus@bakerbotts.com>, Robert Edwards <robert.edwards@troutmansanders.com>, Robert Fallon <FallonR@dsmo.com>, Robert Steiner <RSteiner@luce.com>, Scott Harris <scott.harris@nrgenergy.com>, Shohet, Jeff <jshohet@graycary.com>, Stephen Raber <sraber@wc.com>, Terry Houlihan <thoulihan@mdbe.com>, Thomas Hixson <thixson@mdbe.com>, Thomas Kennedy <tkennedy@mdbe.com>, Tim Muller <tim.muller@williams.com>, Timothy Taylor <ttaylor@smrh.com>, Veronica Proctor <ProctorV@dsmo.com>, Zackary Starbird <zack.starbird@southernenergy.com>
X-cc: 
X-bcc: 
X-Folder: \Sanders, Richard B (Non-Privileged)\Sanders, Richard B.\PX
X-Origin: Sanders-R
X-FileName: Sanders, Richard B (Non-Privileged).pst

Here is a copy of the ninth circuits opinion filed this afternoon in Duke
Energy v. Gray Davis enjoining the comandeering of the block forward
contracts.


 <<0155770.pdfopenelement.pdf>>

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

[INFO] -- Content Manager:

NOTICE:  This email message is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential and privileged information.  Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited.  If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply email and destroy all copies of the original message.

To contact our email administrator directly, send to postmaster@graycary.com

Thank you.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

 - 0155770.pdfopenelement.pdf 